|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 132-137
Blood alcohol levels in road traffic accidents: Factors associated and the relationship between history of alcohol consumption and blood alcohol level detection
Kundavaram Paul Prabhakar Abhilash1, Devraj Lath2, J Kowshik1, Arun Jose2, Gina Maryann Chandy1
1 Department of Emergency Medicine, Christian Medical College, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India
2 Department of Clinical Biochemistry, Christian Medical College, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India
|Date of Submission||28-May-2019|
|Date of Acceptance||18-Jul-2019|
|Date of Web Publication||30-Sep-2019|
Dr. Gina Maryann Chandy
Department of Emergency Medicine, Christian Medical College, Vellore - 632 004, Tamil Nadu
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Introduction: Alcohol consumption contributes to a significant number of road traffic accidents (RTAs), and data regarding the reliability of history and blood alcohol content (BAC) in RTA victims are scant.
Methodology: This retrospective study was conducted in the emergency departments (EDs) over 6 weeks. All adult RTAs presenting within 12 h of the incident were included for analysis.
Results: The study cohort included 369 RTA patients, with the mean interval before presentation being 3 h (standard deviation: 2.22). Two-wheeler accidents (77.2%) were the predominant mode of injury. Usage of a helmet and seat belt was documented in a meager (6.4% [17/267] and 8.8% [3/34], respectively). A positive history of alcohol consumption was reported by 19.5% of cases (72/369). However, BAC was detectable in 30.1% of cases (111/369), with an alarming 19.78% (73/369) being above the legal limit for driving. Nearly 77.5% (86/111) of those who tested positive for alcohol consumption were driving the vehicle involved. Positive BAC levels showed a significant association with young age (18–39 years), male gender, two-wheeler usage, and between 5 PM and 12 AM.
Conclusion: A history of alcohol consumption leading to an RTA is not reliable in the ED. Hence, measuring BAC levels in all RTA patients provides an objective and reliable form of documentation for medico-legal purposes.
Keywords: Blood alcohol content levels, blood alcohol levels, emergency department, road traffic accidents
|How to cite this article:|
Prabhakar Abhilash KP, Lath D, Kowshik J, Jose A, Chandy GM. Blood alcohol levels in road traffic accidents: Factors associated and the relationship between history of alcohol consumption and blood alcohol level detection. Int J Crit Illn Inj Sci 2019;9:132-7
|How to cite this URL:|
Prabhakar Abhilash KP, Lath D, Kowshik J, Jose A, Chandy GM. Blood alcohol levels in road traffic accidents: Factors associated and the relationship between history of alcohol consumption and blood alcohol level detection. Int J Crit Illn Inj Sci [serial online] 2019 [cited 2019 Dec 16];9:132-7. Available from: http://www.ijciis.org/text.asp?2019/9/3/132/268351
| Introduction|| |
India has a road network of 5,903,293 km, which is the second largest in the world. Road traffic accidents (RTAs) result in the largest number of fatalities and injuries worldwide by injuring 50 million and killing 1.2 million people each year.,,, Drunken driving is a major contributor to traffic deaths in India, which is responsible for 70% of road fatalities.,, As blood alcohol levels increase, there is progressive loss of driving ability due to an increase in reaction time, false confidence, impaired concentration, and decreased auditory and visual acuity. Das et al. reported that alcohol was incriminated in 2%–33% of injuries and 6%–48% of deaths. Esser et al. found that nearly one in six RTA patients is suspected of or reported alcohol use. Studies in India have relied either on postmortem samples or history and examination, with a few utilizing breath analyzers. Tabin et al. used breath analyzers and blood alcohol levels estimated by gas-liquid chromatography, with 22% of cases testing positive. There is a need for capacity building and reporting for substance use in RTA, as evinced by the discrepancies between hospital-based studies and government reports.
Under Section 185 of the Indian Motor Vehicles Act, India, driving with a Blood alcohol concentration (BAC) level above 30 mg/dL is a punishable offense. Evaluation of an RTA patient for alcohol consumption thus carries important legal implications. The existing studies do not tell us if the alcohol consumption is by the driver, pedestrian, or the pillion rider, and hence, the risk of accidents among drunken drivers cannot be assessed. In India, blood alcohol levels are rarely available in most emergency departments (EDs) or trauma centers. Furthermore, a history of alcohol consumption may be unreliable or not forthcoming. No study has been conducted to assess the reliability of history of alcohol consumption in RTA patients. In the present study, we sought to determine the prevalence of alcohol consumption (including above the permissible limit) and the correlation between history and BAC levels and study the various factors associated with alcohol intake. We also studied whether positive BAC levels were associated with poor patient outcomes.
| Methodology|| |
We conducted a retrospective analysis of adult patients presenting with an RTA to determine the factors associated with positive BAC levels and their correlation with a history of alcohol consumption.
We conducted this study in the adult ED of Christian Medical College, Vellore, which is a large tertiary care hospital in South India with 2700 inpatient beds. The adult ED has 49 beds with about 75,000 admissions yearly.
Adults who presented with an alleged history of an RTA presenting within 12 h of the incident, over the 6-week study period from June 15, 2018, to July 30, 2018, were included in the analysis. RTA victims aged below 18 and those presenting after 12 h of the incident were excluded from the study.
Patient data were obtained through the hospital's electronic database. Details of history and physical examination findings and demographic details were recorded on a standard data collection sheet. The variables included age, sex, mechanism of injury, mode of transport, place of occurrence, usage of helmets and seat belts, triage priority, and the type and severity of injury. Triage priority level was defined as follows:
- Triage priority 1: Patients with airway, breathing, or circulation compromise, or head injury with Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) <8
- Triage priority 2: Patients with stable airway, breathing, and circulation with long-bone injuries, dislocations, stable abdomino-thoracic injuries, and head injury with GCS 9 or more
- Triage priority 3: Hemodynamically stable patients with minor trauma.
The severity of injury was assessed using the Revised Trauma Score (RTS). The regions of the body involved were documented, and only significant deep injuries were considered for analysis. These included penetrating trauma, fractures, dislocations, head injury, and other internal organ injuries. Minor abrasions, superficial lacerations, and minor soft-tissue injuries were considered to be superficial injuries and were not included in the analysis. If indicated, initial stabilization was followed by referral for further management to other departments, with admission to the respective wards.
The ED outcome (alive/dead/left against medical advice) and hospital outcome (alive/dead) of the patients were compared between those with positive and negative BAC levels. The history of alcohol consumption was correlated with the BAC levels sent from the ED.
Laboratory test (BAC levels)
BAC levels are sent as a routine protocol for all RTA victims in our ED. Whole blood was collected into 2-ml BD Vacutainer ® tubes with gray rubber stoppers containing 3-mg sodium fluoride and 6-mg sodium Ethylenediaminetetracetic acid (EDTA) as additives to prevent coagulation and fermentation as per the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute standards. These were submitted to the department of clinical biochemistry, for further analysis. The specimens were centrifuged, and plasma was separated and frozen at −20°C till analysis and then discarded. The analysis was performed using a Roche Cobas 8000 analyser (Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany), based on the alcohol dehydrogenase principle. In this method, the enzyme alcohol dehydrogenase oxidizes blood alcohol to acetaldehyde. The corresponding increase in absorbance at 340 nm is due to the generation of NADH + from NAD + (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide), which is proportional to the concentration of alcohol present in the sample. Interassay coefficient of variation was <5% during the study period. The method is highly specific with crossreactivity of 0.8% for N-propanol and 2.8% for N-butanol at a concentration at 2000 mg/L.
The data were entered into Microsoft Excel (version 15.12.3) and were analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (IBM Corp. Released 2015. IBM SPSS, Version 23.0, Armonk, NY, USA). Continuous variables were presented as mean (standard deviation [SD]). Categorical and nominal variables were presented as percentages. The Chi-square test was used to compare dichotomous variables. Univariate analysis was done to determine the factors associated with positive BAC levels. Similarly, the outcomes associated with high BAC levels were compared. For all tests, a two-sided P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB Min. No. 10559 dated 08.08.2018), and patient confidentiality was maintained using unique identifiers and by password-protected data-entry software with restricted users.
| Results|| |
During the study period of 6 weeks, our ED attended to 7044 patients, with 696 being RTA victims. Pediatric and adolescent patients, patients for whom BAC levels were not sent by the ED team, and patients whose blood samples got hemolyzed and could not be processed were excluded from the study. The final study cohort included 369 patients on whom BAC levels were available [Figure 1].
The mean age of the victims was 39.78 (SD: 15.46) years, and there was a male predominance (85.6%). The baseline characteristics and events related to the incident are summarized in [Table 1]. Two-third of the incidents (77.2%) were two-wheeler accidents. The mean time taken to present to the ED was 3 (SD = 2.2) h. Majority of the accidents took place within a 420-km radius of our hospital. Physical examination findings of these patients are shown in [Table 2]. The RTS was used to characterize the severity of the trauma. Only six patients had an RTS <4.
|Table 2: Examination findings at presentation to the emergency departments (n=369)|
Click here to view
There was very poor compliance to road safety rules. Only 6.4% (17/267) of those driving two-wheelers were documented to have worn helmets and 8.8% (3/34) of those in four-wheelers were documented to have used seat belts. Among the 17 people using helmets, 12 (70.6%) did not sustain any serious head injury and none sustained any facial injury. Among the remaining 250 not using helmets, 57 (22.8%) sustained head injuries and 41 (16.4%) sustained facial injuries.
A positive history of alcohol consumption was recorded in only 19.5% (72/369) of all patients. However, BAC levels were positive in 30% of these patients (111/369). A positive history of alcohol consumption was absent in 44.1% (49/111) of those with positive BAC levels. In fact, 65.8% (73/111) of the patients had BAC levels above the legal limit of 30 mg/dL (as stipulated under Section 185, The Motor Vehicles Act). Among the 53 women tested, 5 (9.4%) had detectable alcohol levels, with 1 being above the legal limit for driving, yet only one of them had a positive history of alcohol consumption. The association of detectable blood alcohol levels with age group, triage priority, and role in the RTA is shown in [Table 3].
|Table 3: Association of detectable blood alcohol levels with risk factors and outcome (n=369)|
Click here to view
Two-third (65.8%: 73/111) of the patients with positive BAC levels belonged to the age group of 18–39 years. Among the priority 1 patients evaluated, 42.1% (32/76) had detectable BAC levels. We also evaluated the role of the 111 patients with positive BAC levels in the RTA. A vast majority (77.5%: 86/111) were driving a vehicle, while 17.1% (19/111) were pillion riders/passengers and 4.5% (5/111) were pedestrians. RTAs occurring between 5:00 PM and 12:00 AM were significantly more likely to present with detectable BAC levels when compared to those occurring at other times (odds ratio [OR]: 2.83; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.789–4.482, P = 0.007).
The association between deep injuries sustained and positive blood alcohol levels is shown in [Table 4]. We found that patients with positive BAC levels were almost twice as likely to present with head or facial injuries (OR: 1.78; 95% CI: 1.123–2.806, P = 0.014), when compared to those without detectable blood alcohol levels.
|Table 4: Distribution of injuries with respect to positive blood alcohol concentration levels (n=369)|
Click here to view
Overall, more than half (56.4%) were discharged stable from the ED, and 32% were admitted for further management. Comparison of ED and hospital outcomes of those with and without detectable BAC levels is shown in [Table 5].
| Discussion|| |
Our study showed the association between BAC level positivity and the various factors associated with it. This is one of the very few studies done on BAC levels in the ED. It also highlights the unreliability of history given during an RTA and stresses the need for an objective and quantitative test like BAC level, which is not available or used in most of the EDs in the developing world.
Alcohol is a major risk factor in all RTAs. In our study, we see a third of the patients who presented with RTAs being tested positive for BAC levels. As driving under the influence of alcohol causes imprecise and irrational behavior, there is an increased chance of meeting with an accident. The WHO reports that risks of an accident increase with blood alcohol concentrations (BAC), significantly above 40 mg/dL. A systematic review conducted by Das et al. estimated that alcohol was responsible for 2%–33% of injuries and 6%–48% of deaths in RTAs.
Most studies in India have reported alcohol consumption based on postmortem studies (Baruah and Chaliha), patient history and case notes (Esser et al. and Mohan et al.), or breath analyzers (Kaushik et al.).,,,, Roui et al. in Germany demonstrated that although there may be slight differences between breath alcohol concentrations and blood alcohol concentrations, breath analyzers have weaknesses which can be supplemented by blood alcohol levels. Tabin et al. estimated a 22% prevalence using gas-liquid chromatography in addition to breath analyzers in their study. In Vietnam, Nguyen et al. reported detectable blood alcohol levels in 43.2% of patients.
Motorization has enhanced the lives of many individuals and societies, but the benefits have come with a price. RTA injures or disables between 20 million and 50 million people a year, with the most vulnerable road users being pedestrians, cyclists, two-wheeler riders, and passengers on public transport. Our study showed the dismal road safety practices in our country, with only a minor proportion using helmets (6.4%) or seat belts (8.8%). The majority of patients wearing helmets were protected from head and facial injuries, and in spite of awareness campaigns and helmets being mandatory by law, their usage remains poor.
In the present study, nearly a third (30%) of all patients tested had detectable BAC levels, with only 19.5% (72/369) giving a positive history of alcohol consumption. Alarming is the fact that two-thirds (65.8%) of those with detectable BAC levels were in fact above the legal limit of driving in India. With almost half of these patients (44.1%) denying consumption of alcohol prior to the incident, we conclusively proved that history of alcohol consumption is very unreliable in RTA cases. Hence, BAC levels should be made mandatory as this single test could tip the scales in a medico-legal fight between the two parties. Another important factor to consider in our study is the mean time of patient arrival to the ED from the time of incident which was 3 h. This is much longer than what is documented internationally in places with good prehospital facility. The reasons for this time lag are a substandard prehospital service in India and our hospital being a tertiary care referral center. According to Holford, alcohol follows a one-compartment model with concentration-dependent elimination. At a BAC of 80 mg/dL, equivalent to the Km, the elimination rate is half the maximum elimination capacity of 230 mg/L/h., The implication of this time lag is some BAC levels in those who consumed alcohol may have become negative or would have been within the legal limit of driving.
This study clearly demonstrates that in the ED setting of an RTA, a history of alcohol consumption alone will not suffice. BAC levels provide a rapid, reliable, and objective form of documentation, especially in medico-legal cases where drunken driving constitutes a culpable offense.
| Conclusion|| |
A history of alcohol consumption leading to an RTA is not reliable in the ED. Hence, measuring BAC levels in all RTA patients provides an objective and reliable form of documentation for medico-legal purposes. We, therefore, recommend that BAC levels should be made mandatory for all RTAs and other medico-legal cases in the ED.
Research quality and ethics statement
The authors of this manuscript declare that this scientific work complies with reporting quality, formatting, and reproducibility guidelines set forth by the EQUATOR Network. The authors also attest that this clinical investigation was determined to require IRB/Ethics Committee review, and the corresponding protocol/approval number is IRB Min. No. 10559 dated 08.08.2018. We also certify that we have not plagiarized the contents in this submission and have done a plagiarism check.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
Ethical conduct of research
This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board. The authors followed applicable EQUATOR Network (http://www.equator-network.org/) guidelines during the conduct of this research project.
| References|| |
Ruikar M. National statistics of road traffic accidents in India. J Orthop Traumatol Rehabil 2013;6:1-6. [Full text]
Nguyen NP, Passmore J, Tran LT, Luong AM. Role of alcohol in hospitalized road trauma in Viet Nam. Traffic Inj Prev 2013;14:329-34.
Baruah AM, Chaliha R. A study of incidence of alcohol use in fatal road traffic accidents. J Indian Acad Forensic Med 2015;37:12-5.
Kaushik G, Gupta AA, Lalwani S, Soni KD, Kumar S, Sagar S. The effect of alcohol intoxication on mortality in road traffic injury patients at level I apex trauma centre in India. Biomed J Sci Tech Res 2017;1:488-90.
Das A, Gjerde H, Gopalan SS, Normann PT. Alcohol, drugs, and road traffic crashes in India: A systematic review. Traffic Inj Prev 2012;13:544-53.
Esser MB, Wadhwaniya S, Gupta S, Tetali S, Gururaj G, Stevens KA, et al.
Characteristics associated with alcohol consumption among emergency department patients presenting with road traffic injuries in Hyderabad, India. Injury 2016;47:160-5.
Tabin M, Sharma RK, Murty OP, Bharadwaj DN, Aggarwal P, Murmu LR. Incidence of alcohol related non-fatal road traffic accidents in South Delhi, India. Malayas J Pathol Sci 2007;2:40-51.
Kocak FE, Isiklar OO, Kocak H, Meral A. Comparison of blood ethanol stabilities in different storage periods. Biochem Med (Zagreb) 2015;25:57-63.
Mohan RS, Boruah B, Saikia A, Deka A, Ahmed M. Alcohol intoxication and road traffic accident fatality, Assam. Indian J Basic Appl Med Res 2016;5:114-9.
Roiu I, Birngruber CG, Spencer VC, Wollersen H, Dettmeyer R, Verhoff MA. A comparison of breath – And blood-alcohol test results from real-life policing situations: A one-year study of data from the central Hessian police district in Germany. Forensic Sci Int 2013;232:125-30.
Mahama MN, Kenu E, Bandoh DA, Zakariah AN. Emergency response time and pre-hospital trauma survival rate of the national ambulance service, greater Accra (January – December 2014). BMC Emerg Med 2018;18:33.
Holford NH. Clinical pharmacokinetics of ethanol. Clin Pharmacokinet 1987;13:273-92.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5]