|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 4 | Page : 182-188
Epidemiology and cost-analysis of emergency department patients treated following traffic accidents in Iran: A retrospective cross-sectional study
Anahita Behzadi1, Mohsen Shahba2, Sina Etemadi3, Behzad Mohamadi4, Mehran Karvar5, Yahya Jafari6, Marjan Hedayatipour3
1 Health Services Management Research Center, Institute for Futures Studies in Health, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
2 Department of Neurosurgery, School of Medicine, Kerman University of Medical Science, Kerman, Iran
3 Department of Health Management, Policy and Economics, School of Management and Medical Information Sciences, Kerman University of Medical Science, Kerman, Iran
4 Department of Health Services Management, School of Health, Bam University of Medical Sciences, Bam, Iran
5 Leishmaniasis Research Center, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
6 Department of Health Services Management, School of Public Health, Bam University of Medical Science, Bam, Iran
|Date of Submission||07-Nov-2019|
|Date of Acceptance||03-May-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||29-Dec-2020|
Mr. Behzad Mohamadi
Department of Health Services Management, School of Public Health, Bam University of Medical sciences, Bam
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Introduction: Epidemiological analysis of traffic accidents can provide information for future plans to lower the cost and burden of road traffic accidents (RTAs). This study was aimed to determine the epidemiological characteristics of patients with RTAs.
Methods: We conducted a retrospective cross-sectional study of RTA patients presenting in 2016 to the Emergency Department at Shahid Bahonar Medical Education Center in Kerman, Iran. A checklist including variables such as age, sex, month, in which the patient referred, final outcome, overall cost and the site of injury used to collect data. The diagnostic criteria were in accordance to ICD 10.
Results: Of the total of 3277 patients who were studied, 2713 (82.78%) were men and 564 (16.66%) were women. Most of the accidents occurred at the age group of 16–30 years and the average cost of treatment in the hospital was 2152.45 USD. The most affected area was the lower limb. The majority of accidents occurred in spring and summer. The mortality rate was (2.74%).
Discussion: Injuries and deaths due to RTAs are a major public health problem, especially in young age groups. Therefore, more preventive programs targeting young adults should be considered to reduce the burden of RTAs.
Conclusion: Epidemiology and cost analysis of results showed that men caused more accidents and costs burden for both health system and society. Considering they have a more share of activity, economy and workforce, it will cause more damage and adverse consequences for economy and social life of the society.
Keywords: Cost analysis, emergency, epidemiological, traffic accidents
|How to cite this article:|
Behzadi A, Shahba M, Etemadi S, Mohamadi B, Karvar M, Jafari Y, Hedayatipour M. Epidemiology and cost-analysis of emergency department patients treated following traffic accidents in Iran: A retrospective cross-sectional study. Int J Crit Illn Inj Sci 2020;10:182-8
|How to cite this URL:|
Behzadi A, Shahba M, Etemadi S, Mohamadi B, Karvar M, Jafari Y, Hedayatipour M. Epidemiology and cost-analysis of emergency department patients treated following traffic accidents in Iran: A retrospective cross-sectional study. Int J Crit Illn Inj Sci [serial online] 2020 [cited 2021 Jan 25];10:182-8. Available from: https://www.ijciis.org/text.asp?2020/10/4/182/305305
| Introduction|| |
Today, people use various means of transportation, such as roads, railways, airways, and sea. The most common transportation method is the road. However, road traffic and accidents represent an issue of global impact. Traumatic injuries represent a growing and neglected health crisis in the world, with > 75.5 million Disability-Adjusted Life Years reported all over the world in 2010. Globally, 1.2 million people die annually in road traffic accidents (RTAs), and the rate is rising with low-and-middle income countries (LMIC) experiencing a greater burden. The rate of RTAs in Iran exceeds the global average, with associated costs in 2013 reaching 6% of total gross domestic product (GDP).
This study aimed to evaluate the epidemiology and costs of the medical care of patients admitted following an RTA.
| Methods|| |
The study was a retrospective cross-sectional study of patients admitted for injuries sustained in RTA who presented between March 2016 and March 2017 to Shahid Bahonar Medical Education Center (SBMEC) affiliated with Kerman University of Medical Sciences in Kerman, Iran. Data were obtained from a census of all records. The complete records were extracted from the Health Information System at (SBMEC).
A checklist was used to collect data from Inpatient documents, and it was designed by the researchers and verified by experts (a group of 14 specialists included general surgeon, neurosurgeon, orthopedic surgeon, emergency medicine specialist, thoracic and pulmonary surgeon, maxillofacial surgeon, health-care management specialist, health policy specialist, health economist, the head of the nursery, the head of the intensive care unit, the chief of hospital, a representative of clinical and a representative of public health deputies of university). This checklist contains various demographic and epidemiological information such as age, sex, type of traumatic injury, total cost expenditures, and emergency department disposition (death, admission, discharge, etc.).
In this study, the site of injuries is categorized into nine groups: head and neck, face, chest, abdomen and pelvis, spinal cord, upper limb and lower limb, other injuries, not specified, and multiple injuries. Age was stratified into five categories: (please list the categories). To estimate the overall cost of each patient from the providers' prospective (the hospital), all direct hospital costs recorded in the patient's file, including radiography costs, medications in the department, surgeries, specialists visit, and laboratory tests. Human resource costs were excluded due to the inability to accurately quantify these costs per patient in this health-care system.
Data entry and statistical analysis were performed using International Business Machines (IBM) Statistical Package for the Social Science (SPSS) V22.0 (IBM, Armonk, USA).
Regarding the normal distribution of data, researchers used parametric t-test for comparing the mean of binominal variables and ANOVA test for comparing average costs in different groups while using its post hoc tests, Tuckey and Bonferroni, to find out if there is any significant relationship between the two groups of variables, separately. Hence, there was a significant relationship of costs among different groups of sex, age, the month of visit, site of injury, and the patient's outcome (P < 0.05).
| Results|| |
In this study, a total of 3277 patients were investigated. The patients' age range was between 3 and 37 years old with a mean age of (30.13), standard deviation(16.33). As for gender, 2713 (82.78%) of patients were male and 564 (16.66%) were female [Table 1].
|Table 1: Distribution of accidents based on age, injury region, age group, referral month, and final outcome for the patient|
Click here to view
The lowest and the highest costs of health-care services were 26.65 and 67,301USD, with a mean cost of 2152.45 USD, totally. The mean costs were 2231.80 USD for men and 1770.76 USD for women. The t-test results showed a significant difference of costs among men and women groups (P = 0.002).
The lowest and the highest rate of accidents were reported in the >60 years (211 patients) and 16–30 years (1504 patient) age-groups, respectively. Tukey's test results for comparing hospital costs between different age-groups are presented [Table 2]. The ANOVA test showed a significant difference of hospital costs among different age groups. In contrast, the results of Tukey's test demonstrated more details as a significant difference between costs in age-Group 1 (<15 years), age-Group 3 (31–45 years) and the age-Group 4 (45–60 years) (P = 0.003).
The rates of injury patterns are displayed in [Table 1], with lower limb injuries accounting for the greatest injury burden (34.26%), while abdomen and pelvic trauma accounted for the least (1.15%).
Overall, (3201) patients were discharged home, 85 (2.59%) patients signed out of the hospital against medical advice (AMA), (3277) patients were admitted to the hospital, and 90 (2.74%) died.
The results of the ANOVA test, including Tukey and Bonferroni, showed a significant difference between the hospital costs in patients with different outcomes (P < 0.0001) except for the group that was discharged with personal consent [Table 3]. Using the ANOVA test, there was a significant difference between sites of injuries (P < 0.0001) [Table 4]. The frequency of patients based on the site of injuries is shown in [Table 1]. Most injuries were in the lower limb (34.26%) and the lowest damages related to the abdomen and pelvic (1.15%).
|Table 3: The Tukey test results for the costs of outcomes for each patient|
Click here to view
|Table 4: The Bonferroni test results for the costs in the site of injuries|
Click here to view
| Discission|| |
The financial burden of health-care services dedicated to traffic accidents in Iran consumes a large share of GDP, and if the loss of workforce and financial opportunities is factored in this equation, this figure would be more exorbitant.
According to the WHO estimates, RTAs costs 1% of GDP in low-income countries, while in average and high-income countries, they account for 1.5 and 2% of GDP, respectively. However, studies conducted in Iran show that the cost of RTAs equaled 7% of GDP in 2007.
Men are more likely to be involved in traffic accidents. Most of the patients who referred to the SBMEC ED due to RTAs were men (82.87%). Considering that men play a more significant role in the transportation system, it is natural for men to suffer more from traffic accidents. In a study by Nguyen, 25% of subjects were female and 75% were male. Furthermore, according to the WHO report in 2004, men are three times more likely than women to suffer from traffic accidents. Another main study in Iran showed 73% of dead were men and the rest were women too. These reports are consistent with our results. The remarkable rate of male involvement in traffic accidents could be due to the fact that men drive carelessly and aggressively. In addition, cultural issues such as restriction of riding motorcycle by women in Iran can contribute to the growing rate of accidents by male.
Our results showed that the hospital costs of male patients were significantly higher than female ones. Since men play an important role in the national economy and Gross National Product of Iran, the accident-induced damages inflicted on this group can have adverse consequences for the economy and social dimensions in future.
In some countries like Iran, Men are more responsible for the livelihood of the family than women, they are more physically active in society, and of course they drive more and cause more accidents and therefore more costs. Culturally, men drive faster than women and cause more serious accidents and more physical injuries. As noted above, men are more likely to incur high costs to the health-care system due to severe accidents, and because they make up the bulk of the workforce, they ultimately cause more damage to the community's economy.
Another study revealed RTA injuries and deaths increased from 1997 to 2005 among both males and females. Men/women ratio for RTA fatalities was 4.2/1 in Iran, which is comparable to previous studies. Gender differences in RTA show that men cause higher risks. The distribution of global RTA deaths by gender shown that men are responsible for more deaths than women (27.6 versus 10.4 per 100 000 populations, respectively).
There are different reports on RTA which showed men/women ratio in the world including 9.6/1 in Thailand's rural areas, 2.4/1 in the USA, 2.1/1 in AddisAbaba and Ethiopia.
Patients were categorized in different age groups. The highest number of accidents was observed in group two (16–30 years). Police reports in Iran reveal that men aged 26–33 have the highest rate of accidents while women of the same age have the lowest rate of traffic accidents. Aygencel reported a mean age of 35.5 years for admitted patients. Furthermore, in the study of Cetinoglu and Marmor, a mean age of 25 and 27 years were reported, respectively.,, In a study in England, men aged 16–34 are at a higher risk for RTAs. These reports are consistent with our results which demonstrate the significant effect of accidents on the young and productive classes of society, along with the fact that devastating health and medical costs reduce the workforce and social activities of this group in the society. On the other hand, the high rate of accidents in this age group could be ascribed to their greater involvement in the workforce while they drive more alone and are more likely to drive faster or recklessly which point to their lack of familiarity with driving rules, the importance of useful use of young age, feeling of being responsible for their own's health and so the society, which demands further emphasis on proper trainings for the youths. There was a significant difference between the age groups in terms of treatment costs so that subjects in group 1 (<15 years), group 3 (31–45 years) and group 4 (45–60 years) paid the highest costs for traffic accidents.
It could be justified by that adults may suffer from more severe injuries and require greater health cares in comparison to individuals under the age of 15 years. It also imposes heavier costs on the health system. It seems that adults are more likely to drive and more likely to drive faster and then more likely to be traumatized.
The highest rate of injuries induced by traffic accidents was recorded in the summer, especially in August [10.95%; [Table 4]]. In the same vein, Sehat et al. showed that the highest rate of accidents belonged to August (17.9%). Furthermore, Karadanas revealed that this figure was especially high during summer (May, June, July). It may be due to larger number of road trips during summer, which naturally leads to more accidents. Therefore, greater attention to roads traffic through making rules, penalties or any kind of regulation for public transportation during these risky months can help gain more control over transportation and prevent more accidents.
From a pathological standpoint, the results showed that the most damages were related to the lower extremities (34.26%) [Table 4]. Similarly, Nguyen et al. reported the most severe injuries (44%) were observed in lower limbs, but in Parkinson's study, damages were common in the upper limbs. In other study, head injury was cited as the most frequent injury, whereas in the present study, it was ranked sixth. The anatomical condition of hands and feet make them more susceptible to injuries, though the site of injury is depended on the type of accident and the vehicle.
In the present study, most of the patients were discharged by the order of the physician that suggests most patients stayed in hospital until the end of their treatment period, at the same time Devos showed 5.6% of patients who referred to the emergency medicine ward died because of accident and 94.4% survived. Furthermore, another study results showed that 72.5% of referred patients were discharged and 12.7% were discharged AMA, 10.2% admitted to related hospital wards and 4.7% of them died.
In Iran, according to Article 37 of the 5th Development plan law, the Ministry of Health and Medical Education is required to take the necessary measures for the immediate and unconditional treatment of injured people in accidents and accidents in all governmental and nongovernmental healthcare facilities as well as on the route of deployment To the specialized centers and to the next necessary visits, although this article emerged under Article 92 from the 4th Development Plan law in Iran since 2005, resulted in the fact that every patient had sufficient evidence of an accident brought to the hospital without need to pay, to be admitted and to receive health care as soon as possible. It seems that such article' law may reinforce the attitude of citizens to be not only more careful about your health but also more careless in every aspect of their traffic behavior including driving, respecting to traffic rules and so on unconsciously, which could be because of the health-care services which may need in result, were free of charge for the patients themselves.
According to the WHO 2002 report, around 1/183/000 people died in RTAs and RTAs were the eighth leading cause of death. According to 2016 report, RTAs have caused the deaths of 1/350/000 people around the world and remained the eighth leading cause of death for all age groups, and the first cause of death for children and young adults (15–29).
Figure shows the difference in fatalities due to traffic accidents in Iran and 18 countries based on the number of deaths per 100,000 that compares traffic accident casualties in Iran and other countries [Table 5].
|Table 5: The comparative statistics of on traffic accident casualties in high, middle and low income countries based on the number of deaths per 100,000 populations|
Click here to view
The incidence of traffic accidents in LMICs is three times higher than in developed and high-income countries, and unfortunately, there has been no decrease in the number of traffic accidents in LMICs since 2013. The comparative study findings that are presented below show the number of people killed in traffic accidents in 18 selected countries according to their net per capita income and population, as well as the type of country by income (high-, middle-, and low-income countries) which obviously shows LMICs have very high rates of traffic fatalities, significantly more than high-income countries [Table 5].
According to a 2018 World Health Organization report, traffic accident deaths in six areas are depicted in [Table 5]. Analogous to the legal efforts of the greater international community to reduce RTAs, Iran has similarly introduced legislation mandating helmet use for those on motorcycles and seat belt use by all vehicle occupants, installation of speed enforcement cameras, prohibitions of driving while intoxicated guidelines for the replacement of older model vehicles, and standards for compensation for victims of fatal RTAs. Even so, RTA rates continue to rise in Iran highlighting the need for further government attention and resource allocation [Figure 1].
|Figure 1: The rates of road traffic death per 100,000 population by the WHO regions|
Click here to view
A multifactorial approach is needed to curb the surge in Iran's RTA epidemic. Beyond simple law enforcement measures and legal statute modifications, improvements in transportation infrastructure and driver training are also needed.
In this research, cost data were not completely obtained and researchers could not analysis of indirect cost and financial burden from the perspective of the patient.
Authors need to appreciate to School of Management and Medical Information Sciences, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, School of Health, Bam University of Medical Sciences, SBMEC in the city of Kerman and special thanks to Dr. Sajjad Khosravi, who coordinated data collection process and arranged the necessary permissions and improvements.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
Research quality and ethics statement
This study was approved by the local Institutional Review Board / Ethics Committee. The authors followed applicable EQUATOR Network (http://www.equator-network.org/) guidelines, during the conduct of this research project.
| References|| |
Özen E, Genc E, Kaya Z. Estimation of the costs of traffic accidents in turkey: An evaluation in terms of the insurance and financial system. Journal of Yaşar University 2014;9:5649-73.
Kumar GA, Dilip TR, Dandona L, Dandona R. Burden of out-of-pocket expenditure for road traffic injuries in urban India. BMC Health Serv Res 2012;12:285.
Murray CJ, Vos T, Lozano R, Naghavi M, Flaxman AD, Michaud C, et al
. Disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) for 291 diseases and injuries in 21 regions, 1990-2010: A systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010. Lancet 2012;380:2197-223.
Staton C, Vissoci J, Gong E, Toomey N, Wafula R, Abdelgadir J, et al
. Road traffic injury prevention initiatives: A systematic review and metasummary of effectiveness in low and middle income countries. PLoS One 2016;11:e0144971.
Organization WH. Global Status Report on Road Safety 2015: World Health Organization; 2015.
Nguyen H, Ivers RQ, Jan S, Martiniuk AL, Li Q, Pham C. The economic burden of road traffic injuries: evidence from a provincial general hospital in Vietnam. Inj Prev 2013;19:79-84.
Rezaei S, Akbari SA, Arab M, Ghasempour S. Economic burden of road traffic crashes in Tehran province, Iran in 2009. Health Inform Manag 2013;10:1-12.
Peden M, Scurfield R, Sleet D, Mohan D, Hyder AA, Jarawan E, et al
. World Report on Road Traffic Injury Prevention. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2004.
Ainy E, Soori H, Ganjali M, Baghfalaki T. Road traffic injury cost estimation by willingness to pay method. Saf Promot Inj Prevent 2014;2:215-25.
Rasouli MR, Nouri M, Zarei MR, Saadat S, Rahimi-Movaghar V. Comparison of road traffic fatalities and injuries in Iran with other countries. Chin J Traumatol 2008;11:131-4.
Roudsari BS, Sharzei K, Zargar M. Sex and age distribution in transport-related injuries in Tehran. Accid Anal Prev 2004;36:391-8.
Monárrez-Espino J, Hasselberg M, Laflamme L. First year as a licensed car driver: Gender differences in crash experience. Saf Sci 2006;44:75-85.
Peden M. Global collaboration on road traffic injury prevention. Int J Inj Contr Saf Promot 2005;12:85-91.
Swaddiwudhipong W, Nguntra P, Mahasakpan P, Koonchote S, Tantriratna G. Epidemiologic characteristics of drivers, vehicles, pedestrians and road environments involved in road traffic injuries in rural Thailand. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 1994;25:37-44.
Administration NHTS, (NHTSA). Comparison of Crash Fatalities by Gender and Year from 1996-2005: NHTSA's National Center for Statistic and Analysis; 2007. Available from: http://www. nhtsa.gov
. [Last accessed on 2019 Oct 24].
Dessie T, Larson CP. The occurrence and driver characteristics associated with motor vehicle injuries in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. J Trop Med Hyg 1991;94:395-400.
Mohammadi G. The pattern of fatalities by age, seat belt usage and time of day on road accidents. Int J Inj Contr Saf Promot 2009;16:27-33.
Aygencel G, Karamercan M, Ergin M, Telatar G. Review of traffic accident cases presenting to an adult emergency service in Turkey. J Forensic Leg Med 2008;15:1-6.
Çetinoğlu E, Canbaz S, Tomak L, Pekşen Y. Evaluation of road traffic crashes among admittances to 112 emergency healthcare services in Samsun 2004. Turkish J Emerg Med 2007;7:1-4.
Marmor M, Parnes N, Aladgem D, Birshan V, Sorkine P, Halpern P. Characteristics of road traffic accidents treated in an urban trauma center. Isr Med Assoc J 2005;7:9-12.
Holland C, Hill R. The effect of age, gender and driver status on pedestrians' intentions to cross the road in risky situations. Accid Anal Prev 2007;39:224-37.
Sehat M, Naieni KH, Asadi-Lari M, Foroushani AR, Malek-Afzali H. Socioeconomic Status and Incidence of Traffic Accidents in Metropolitan Tehran: A Population-based Study. Int J Prev Med 2012;3:181-90.
Akgül Karadana G, Metin Aksu N, Akkaş M, Akman C, Üzümcügil A, Özmen MM. The epidemiology and cost analysis of patients presented to Emergency Department following traffic accidents. Med Sci Monit 2013;19:1125-30.
Parkinson F, Kent SJ, Aldous C, Oosthuizen G, Clarke D. The hospital cost of road traffic accidents at a South African regional trauma centre: a micro-costing study. Injury 2014;45:342-5.
Weninger P, Hertz H. Factors influencing the injury pattern and injury severity after high speed motor vehicle accident--a retrospective study. Resuscitation 2007;75:35-41.
Devos S, van Belleghem G, van Lier T, Annemans L, Putman K. Attributable health care costs of traffic victims until 1 year after hospitalisation. J Trans Health 2017;4:171-9.
Mahdian M, Sehat M, Fazel MR, Moraveji A, Mohammadzadeh M. Epidemiology of urban traffic accident victims hospitalized more than 24 h in a level III trauma center, Kashan county, Iran, during 2012-2013. Arch Trauma Res 2015;4:e28465. DOI: 10.5812/atr.4(2)2015.28465.
Aderyani MR, Naeeni MS, Musavi F, Salehnia E, Dehghani A, Barati M, et al. Exploring the Status of Executing Traffic Accidents Insurance (article 92 of Islamic Republic of Iran's fourth budget plan) According to the Financial Scale of Special Incomes and Non-Settled Traffic Accidents Files at Kashani Hospital of Isfahan; 2015.
World Health Organization. Global Status Report on Road Safety 2018: Summary. World Health Organization; 2018.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5]